In recent months, investors have been pulling hundreds of millions of dollars out of stock funds that invest mainly in companies associated with the big four emerging market nations of Brazil, Russia, India and China.
But it’s China that is causing most of the worry for fund investors, amid signs that the world’s second-largest economy is slowing more sharply than expected.
Even emerging market bull Jim O’Neill, chairman of Goldman Sachs Asset Management, who famously coined the BRIC acronym, said he’s been a bit surprised by the slowdown in China. But that said, O’Neill remains convinced China’s economy will be more than enough to make-up for any weakness in the other BRIC nations.
“It is making the trajectory that I predicted difficult to stick with,” O’Neill said about the slowdown. But he added, “I find it hilarious that people question the thesis on the basis of two quarters.”
The second-quarter was not kind to so-called BRIC-focused stock funds, with investors redeeming $787 million during the period, according to fund tracking firm EPFR. Chinese-focused funds were hit particularly hard, with investor redemptions totalling 88 percent of the $1.6 billion in new money those funds took in during the first quarter.
The rush of money out of Chinese funds come as institutional investors are dialing back growth estimates. In a recent report, Ray Dalio’s Bridgewater Associates attributed “about half” of the slowdown in global growth “to the slowdown in China.”
One sign of the Chinese slowdown can be seen in China’s purchasing managers index which dropped to 50.2 in June after hitting a year-long high of 53.3 in May.
The growing concern about China and slower growth in the other BRIC nations is also starting to show up in the performance of some U.S. emerging markets funds and hedge funds focused on Asia.
Mutual fund industry tracking firm Morningstar says U.S. emerging market stock funds were up 4.61 percent as of June 30, compared to a 5.51 percent gain for non-emerging market stock funds.
China-focused U.S. mutual funds are up 2.9 percent, lagging behind the 4.15 percent gain recorded by diversified emerging market stock funds, according to Morningstar.
The benchmark S&P 500 index, meanwhile, is up about 7 percent this year.
Some Asia-focused hedge funds that go long and short stocks are posting mediocre numbers. HSBC Private
Bank reports the Chilton China Opportunities Fund was up a little under 1 percent as of June 22, while the Pinpoint China Class A Fund was up about 1.3 percent over the same period.
As a whole, however, emerging market stock funds are performing far better than last year, when the group posted a 20 percent decline. But after a fast 13.1 percent gain in the first quarter of 2012, emerging market funds as a group gave back more than half of those gains in the second-quarter.
Now the worry is that with China’s economy slowing, emerging market funds may see further losses in the second-half of 2012, especially if other BRIC nations experience even slower growth.
Bill Rocco, a Morningstar analyst, said China is showing that it is vulnerable to the financial crisis in Europe and the less than robust economy in the U.S.
“I’m always wary of people trying to pick this market or that market,” he said.
On top of that, some investors are beginning to become more cautious about China’s growth estimates.
Cameron Brandt, director of research for EPFR Global, said investors are showing “growing discomfit with official statistics” from China.
Then again, recent history suggests that emerging market countries will still outperform the rest of the world. From 2009 to 2011, the economies of the BRIC nations grew at rates that were 2 to 3 percentage points higher than most other nations, including Europe and the U.S.
BRIC boosters like O’Neill point out that even if China’s growth slows it will still far outpace the average 2.8 percent growth recorded last year by the G-20 nations. The most recent World Bank estimate is that China’s gross domestic product for 2012 will be 8.2 percent, down from 9.2 percent last year and 10.4 percent in 2010.
Jean-Charles Sambor, director of fixed income at $1.7 billion Everest Capital, a Miami hedge fund that focuses on emerging markets, said what is happening in China and the other BRIC nations is that economic growth is returning to a more sustainable level. He said Chinese export growth for the year is around 12.7 percent after hitting 20 percent in 2010. Some of that is the result of economic woes elsewhere.
“The rebalancing towards less export-driven to domestic consumption … is happening in most BRIC countries and most emerging markets,” said Sambor. “The story remains very strong.”